Chalk and literacy

[Batman]

In order to have written the GSG JtR must have had a chalk piece.

He may have planned the GSG and bought the chalk beforehand and so its a useless clue.

He dropped the apron, saw the chalk lying there and scribbled with it (means yet another random/chance JtR event to accept).

He was carrying chalk because it was something he used at work.

Tailor's chalk?
Teachers chalk?
Went playing darts for awhile and borrowed it after?

GSG means JtR is literate although writing in cockney.

The tailor's chalk idea certainly bolsters Kozminski as a suspect, but would Kozminski have learned to write english cockney so quickly?

[lynn cates]

supposition

Hello Batman.

"GSG means JtR is literate although writing in cockney."

But why suppose he did it?

Cheers.
LC

[DVV]

But why suppose he did it?

Cheers.
LC

Indeed, Lynn.
Just a murder and one clue left behind.
Almost nothing.

Cheers

[Batman]

Hello Batman.

"GSG means JtR is literate although writing in cockney."

But why suppose he did it?

Cheers.
LC

Warren who had the GCG removed was heavily critized as probably getting rid of the only real clue they had. It was a turning point that influenced his resignation. By today's standards a law enforcement official who did that at the crime scene would likely be tried and charged with obstructing the cause of justice and destroying evidence. I think the random chance drop of an apron landing at a zone of antisemeticism following a witness earlier claiming to have seen Stride and been called the antisemetical word 'lispki' to be too much of stretch for yet another 'random chance event' to accept.

While I respect Martin Fido and his book, Crimes and Detection of, its obvious the reason he doesn't think Stride is a JtR victim is because his suspect is a Jew.

[Trevor Marriott]

Warren who had the GCG removed was heavily critized as probably getting rid of the only real clue they had. It was a turning point that influenced his resignation. By today's standards a law enforcement official who did that at the crime scene would likely be tried and charged with obstructing the cause of justice and destroying evidence. I think the random chance drop of an apron landing at a zone of antisemeticism following a witness earlier claiming to have seen Stride and been called the antisemetical word 'lispki' to be too much of stretch for yet another 'random chance event' to accept.

While I respect Martin Fido and his book, Crimes and Detection of, its obvious the reason he doesn't think Stride is a JtR victim is because his suspect is a Jew.

The facts that suggest Stride was not killed by the same hand are clear to see for all. But of course there are those that do not want to see. There are so many factors which stand out a mile making her murder different

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00KNRE4NY

[lynn cates]

clue

Hello David. Thanks.

Ah! That would be the apron. Yes, the ONLY clue.

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

qq

Hello Batman. Thanks.

1. Why is it anti-Semitic?

2. What do probabilities get us?

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

substitutio salva veritate

Hello Trevor. Good.

Now, substitute the word "Eddowes" for "Stride" and we shall be in league.

Cheers.
LC

[Batman]

The facts that suggest Stride was not killed by the same hand are clear to see for all. But of course there are those that do not want to see. There are so many factors which stand out a mile making her murder different

www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00KNRE4NY

What I find that stands out a mile is that the same people who reject Stride's murder as just random chance tend to then later go on and connect completely random chance characters who happened to be Jewish and in an insane asylum with the right behavioural problems as JtR might have following Kelly's murder, i.e - David Cohen

Stride neck was slit in the same double manner as the other canonical victims.

The other thing is there are researchers who think Kelly was not a JtR victim. Yet they tend to accept Stride. Why not reject both Stide and Kelly since the same level of doubt/skepticism can be present in each.

If one rejects stride as a JtR victim I think one would have to be globally skeptical about all the other victims too.

If GSG was from JtR then its a major clue. He has chalk. He is literate. He can write cockney.

Foreign Jew? Not likely.

[lynn cates]

beg to differ

Hello Batman.

"Stride's neck was slit in the same double manner as the other canonical victims."

Not so. ONLY Polly and Annie had the double, parallel cuts. Make of THAT what you will.

Cheers.
LC

[DVV]

Hello David. Thanks.

Yes, the ONLY clue.

Cheers.
LC

Ever left.
Purposely.

Cheers

[lynn cates]

emendation

Hello David. Thanks.

Very well.

Cheers.
LC

[Trevor Marriott]

Hello Trevor. Good.

Now, substitute the word "Eddowes" for "Stride" and we shall be in league.

Cheers.
LC

If they ever make another Batman movie I hope they cast you as The Riddler

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00KNRE4NY

[lynn cates]

Joker

Hello Trevor. Thanks.

Nah, I'd be the Joker. (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[DVV]

Hello David. Thanks.

Very well.

Cheers.
LC

Don't get me wrong, Lynn.
I meant Spooner left the apron where it was found, and purposely.