Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Parallels with Columbine?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Parallels with Columbine?

    Hi all,

    I’m reading “Columbine” by Dave Cullen, an excellent account of that tragedy in ’98.. I’m not sure if this thread will be worth anything but I’ve noticed some strange parallels that I find compelling. I’ll list a few points:

    1) The leader was a textbook psychopath, the follower a depressive suicidal; together they formed a lethal dyad.

    2) Some upper level officials were informed of a search warrant that was issued on the young psychopath a year or more before the tragedy – they never served it – the sheriff’s office was also alerted as many as 15 times by one family accusing the young man of criminal behavior – this was also ignored. After the event, investigating cops and detectives were unaware of the above and the informed officials denied any knowledge to the media, Feds etc. They had a CYA meeting where silence was agreed upon.

    3) The media disseminated reams of nonsense due to some misunderstandings; stuff about the trench coat mafia, targeting of jocks and other bullies etc. A feedback loop - with students who heard and then repeated - solidified the nonsense in the public conscious.

    4) Eyewitness accounts were extremely unreliable, in most cases due to reasonable mistakes; i.e., the boys wore trench coats which were later discarded creating in some minds many shooters, the ricocheting of bullets in an echoing schoolhouse made shooters seem close by when in fact they weren’t, a maintenance man on the roof dressed in black was mistaken for a shooter etc..

    Obviously the above says much about the media, eyewitnesses and upper level official behavior in a crisis. These are our sources in the 123 year old JTR case…………Hmmmmm

    On a related note: The psychopath (Eric Harris) and the depressive (Dylan Klebold) planned their attack to an amazing degree, especially Eric. It’s extremely fortuitous that he didn’t understand electrical wiring in bombs or the death toll would have been in the hundreds or beyond. Both boys were highly intelligent.

    In the Virginia Tech shooting it appears the murderer was schizophrenic. He was 23 years old. He also planned his rampage with a fair degree of diligence. There was indeed some organization!

    I expect the parallels with some of our discussions are obvious. I’m not exactly sure what my point is other than to generate some feedback on how the above affects our analysis of this ice cold case…

    Greg

  • #2
    I may prove to be in a minority, but I don't really see any parallels - sorry.

    1) We don't know who or "what" the Ripper was, and I didn't think the collective view was that he had an accomplice.

    2) I am unaware that "officials" or anyone else were warned (in advance) of the Ripper murders, or covered anything up (far-fetched conspiracy theories apart!).

    3) The media may have disseminated reams of nonsense due to some misunderstandings, but isn't that true in almost every case?

    4) Eyewitness accounts were extremely unreliable - again, isn't that a common phenomena?

    So, I regret, I don't think your post will influence me in any appreciable way.

    Phil

    Comment


    • #3
      I read that book too, it was excellent. Great to see all the myths of Columbine disspelled, even the "feel good" ones that people really wanted to believe. I think the truth is always best in the end.

      Parallels with the Ripper? Perhaps just in a very general sense that Eric Harris was a classic psychopath as the Ripper is likely to have been, and that he left some really, really nasty things behind in his journals about what he wanted to do to people, including rape fantasies about the younger girls in his school in which he said he'd like to just "tear them apart like a wolf."

      Harris was pure evil. The book made it very satisfying to discover just how little of his grand plan he actually managed to carry out.

      Comment


      • #4
        Psychopathology...

        Agreed Kensei.

        The tragedy was the sole doing of a young super psychopath who managed to wring a vulnerable lad into his trap. The media perpetrated nonsense.

        I think my point was that we have dishonest officials, sensationalist media and poor eyewitnesses - sound familiar? The human condition I suppose...

        A secondary point was - a schizophrenic is capable of planning......apparently at least under some conditions.............


        Greg

        Comment

        Working...
        X