The kidney removal of Catherine Eddowes.

[Fiver]

You need a reality check !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

''You are increasing the volume of your voice, but not the logic of your argument'."

[Fiver]

You would be surprised

Currently, the number agreeing with you is zero.

[Herlock Sholmes]

Currently, the number agreeing with you is zero.

The most staggering part of Trevor’s argument is about his starting point Fiver. In reaction to his claim that the killer wouldn’t have had time I’ve said this.

If you claim that X didn’t have time to do Y then you HAVE to know the minimum time that Y could have taken to do and what was the maximum time that X had available to him.

You can’t get more basic than that. But when I asked Trevor if he accepted the point he said “but we don’t know how long he had!”

How can anyone not understand this point? I can only conclude that Trevor does understand it but he’ll say absolutely anything rather than accept an inarguable point.

[Herlock Sholmes]

''You are increasing the volume of your voice, but not the logic of your argument'."

I won’t mention names but there are two posters on here who love asking questions and making statements but they just will not answer and straight question.

[FrankO]

This was brought up on a previous thread some time ago, and I suggested that the probable reason for getting Dr Phillips to study the sieved remains of the fire would be for evidence of a burnt heart. I couldn't think of any other reason to involve a police surgeon.

I missed it on the other thread then, DW, but I was thinking exactly the same thing as you regarding the motive behind the sieving of the remains of the fire by those medical men.

Perhaps someone should open a thread on Kelly's heart - we are doing it to death on this thread!

Although, of course, it's quite unbelievable why we are or need to be doing it to death, isn't it?

[Fiver]

I won’t mention names but there are two posters on here who love asking questions and making statements but they just will not answer and straight question.

Only two?

[Herlock Sholmes]

Only two?

[John Wheat]

I won’t mention names but there are two posters on here who love asking questions and making statements but they just will not answer and straight question.

Don't forget those on the Maybrick threads.

[The Rookie Detective]

Surgeon
Doctor
Medical/Surgical Student
Slaughterer
Butcher
Coroner
Convicted murderer
Surgical Skill
Anatomical knowledge
Skilled with a large sharp knife.



Any suspect or person of interest who doesn't fit into one of the above, was not the Ripper.


That's Lechmere, Maybrick and Kosminski gone then.


It doesn't matter why the killer took a Kidney that's important, it's HOW the killer able to do what he literally did, in relative darkness and within a very limited time frame.

How?!

[Geddy2112]

It doesn't matter why the killer took a Kidney that's important, it's HOW the killer able to do what he literally did, in relative darkness and within a very limited time frame.

Do you think he specifically targeted the kidney or did he just take 'something.' Just odd to think if indeed, as per Trevor there were organ thieves at work why did they not take both kidneys or more organs to sell?