Originally posted by sdreid
View Post
Notable Murder Stories That Somehow Don't Sound True
1) Sawney Bean (no ancient records of this cannibal murder family has turned up in Scotland)
2) Bela Kiss (supposedly a serial killer of women in old Austria-Hungary, who manages to remain one step ahead of the law - including using another dead soldier's identity papers to flee - some say he ended up working peacefully as a janitor in New York City's "Yorkville" section of Manhattan into the 1950s!)
3) Sweeny Todd (in original Thomas Peckett Press novel, "A String of Pearls", of 1844, the story of the evil barber and meat supplier is set in 1782, and the title says "founded on fact"; one study of the novel and it's background suggests two incidents of that period of a lunatic who may have cut two throats, but many dispute this finding.)
4) Florence Maybrick (a possible poisoning of a brutal husband by his unfaithful wife, but a strong possibility of the victim poisoning himself with arsenic used as a tonic and self applied medicine - or of being accidentally poisoned.)
5) Eliza Fenning (executed for attempted murder in 1815 of her employer and his family; most scholars feel the evidence is very weak that she did anything to her employers, and the causes of the mass sickness in the household may have been just that - sickness.)
6) Edith Thompson (most commentators of this story feel she did not plan to manipulate Frederick Byswater into killing her husband Percy Thompson; executed due to adultery being played up, poor performance under pressure in witness box, and government refusing to let pathologist it used (Bernard Spilsbury) testify he found no evidence of poison or glass in Percy's body, as Edith's letters to Byswater suggested.)
Leave a comment: