Poll : random victim or not ?

[Rubyretro]

[QUOTE]it's most likely that JTR simply heard her singing[/QUOTE

She surely couldn't have been that bad......

[Malcolm X]

Here's a conspiracy theory for you...

On Wednesday, Sarah Lewis is accosted by some weird 'gent'.

Sarah Lewis has friends in Millers Court.

On Thursday similar 'gent' seen loitering in Millers Court.
(who was he looking for?)

On Friday same 'gent' seen in vicinity and Irish girl found dead in Millers Court.

oh no, not this load of rubbish yet again, i cant wait for BEN to get unbanned in Febuary time, we're going to tear you lot apart

first of all, no rich gent was ever seen loitering inside Millers court ok, this is you believing all the tittle tattle bullshit! .

it's most likely that JTR simply heard her singing, since she was singing for so long, he then lurked around outside between 2 and 3am

[DVV]

The murder looks like she was chosen intentionally, because...

....she was indeed chosen intentionally.

And remember that her murder puts to the "automn of terror".

[K-453]

it occured almost as soon as Barnett left her

If Barnett was not the Ripper, it could hardly have occurred with him being in the room.


Random, I would say. The murder looks like she was chosen intentionally, because A) she was so much mutilated, and B), she was different from the other victims, especially younger.

A) probably comes from opportunity (more time, more pricacy), B) was dictated by circumstances (police and vigilance committees on the streets, also bad weather*).


EDit: * With this I mean, Jack had to take what he could get, even if it was young and pretty.

[DVV]

Hi David

But you might as well say that Eddowes was not random, as she was killed almost as soon as she returned from hop picking.

Hi Robert

hmmm.....no !

[DVV]

Don't forget the "gent" seen again on Sunday morning, Wickerman.

[Wickerman]

Here's a conspiracy theory for you...

On Wednesday, Sarah Lewis is accosted by some weird 'gent'.

Sarah Lewis has friends in Millers Court.

On Thursday similar 'gent' seen loitering in Millers Court.
(who was he looking for?)

On Friday same 'gent' seen in vicinity and Irish girl found dead in Millers Court.

[Robert]

Hi David

But you might as well say that Eddowes was not random, as she was killed almost as soon as she returned from hop picking.

[Addy]

Hi DVV,

You mean, the Ripper knew MJK and intended to kill her?

I personally believe she was a random victim and the Ripper just met her in the street and went with her to her place.

Greetings,

Addy

[DVV]

Imo she was not a random victim.
One point, of course, is the fact that she's been killed indoors.
Another - and more significant - is the fact that it occured almost as soon as Barnett left her (30 Oct).

[DVV]

A simple question about what I consider a crucial point.