Did BS-man murder Liz Stride?

[lynn cates]

club

Hello CD. Thanks.

"I think the best course of action would be for the club members to cooperate with the police as fully as possible."

So do I. And they did. But do you remember what a club member said about the investigation that night? (Hint: it was in that article I published in Rip and was originally in "DAF.")

"And if I were Schwartz, Jewish and new to the country with a wife and newborn, and had been asked to lie and insert myself in a murder investigation, I can imagine my response."

Mine too. but an immigrant might help others in the same boat.

Cheers.
LC

[lynn cates]

Oy gevalt.

Hello Batman.

"I believe the antisemitic GSG to be JtR's rant at Schwartz for disturbing him with Stride."

How would BSM know he were Jewish? Did he detect the odour of knishes as he passed? (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[RockySullivan]

So who was the pipeman in relation to BS man? Did BS man leave & pipeman returned after chasing Schwartz.

[DVV]

Well that's pretty much true of every thread some more than others.

To me, the cachous are extremely important because I think they show that Liz was at ease at the time of her death which again, to me, shows that the B.S. man had left the scene.

c.d.

The fact that she may have been "at ease" at some point, which is possible but is still a speculation, doesn't necessarily mean BSM was gone.
Sometimes you see people that seem about to fight, and five minutes later they take drink together. Such things happen.
At least, we know she did not leave the scene.
So why BSM would have gone ?

[c.d.]

Well that's pretty much true of every thread some more than others.

To me, the cachous are extremely important because I think they show that Liz was at ease at the time of her death which again, to me, shows that the B.S. man had left the scene.

c.d.

[DVV]

Hello Dave,

You are exactly right. But I think the better question is when did Liz take out the cachous?

c.d.

Certainly.
But I remember so many threads about the cachous...leading nowhere.
Now I've decided that JtR had bad breath.
So much that his victims fell to the ground.
Actually, that was an essential part of his MO.

[RockySullivan]

Hello Rocky,

If you look at posts 668 and 670 in this thread, we need to determine when Liz took out the cachous. It would seem to be after the B.S. man left the scene.

c.d.

So did stride have the cachous prior to BS man attack? Where did she get the cachous from? Did it come from
One of the shops within a block or so?

[RockySullivan]

Paul Begg in his facts book believes a case can be made from reports that the man was located and corroborated Schwartz's account.

Well holy hole in a donut batman isn't there any way to find out pipeman's secret identity?

[c.d.]

Hello Dave,

You are exactly right. But I think the better question is when did Liz take out the cachous?

c.d.

[DVV]

Hello Rocky,

If you look at posts 668 and 670 in this thread, we need to determine when Liz took out the cachous. It would seem to be after the B.S. man left the scene.

c.d.

Hi CD,
But when exactly did BSM leave the scene ?
We don't know.

[DVV]

"Antisemite" is a bit too much for 1888, the term having acquired almost a different meaning since WW2.
I'd say ordinary racism/xenophoby.

[c.d.]

Hello Rocky,

If you look at posts 668 and 670 in this thread, we need to determine when Liz took out the cachous. It would seem to be after the B.S. man left the scene.

c.d.

[Batman]

Was Pipeman identified and looked into as a suspect but let go?

Paul Begg in his facts book believes a case can be made from reports that the man was located and corroborated Schwartz's account.

[c.d.]

Sorry, Lynn, but I just can't buy the whole club conspiracy thing basically because I don't see any real need for it. I think the best course of action would be for the club members to cooperate with the police as fully as possible.

And if I were Schwartz, Jewish and new to the country with a wife and newborn, and had been asked to lie and insert myself in a murder investigation, I can imagine my response.

c.d.

[Batman]

I believe the antisemitic GSG to be JtRs rant at Schwartz for disturbing him with Stride.

If this is true its completely rules out Jews and makes JtR a cockney speaking antisemite.