Why did Pipe Man chase Israel Schwartz away?

[Michael W Richards]

Fully agree. BS man is just that, as Lynn Cates once said.

I miss seeing Lynn around here, we agree on may things.

[Lipsky]

Peaked cap man was seen with stride before, during and after she was attacked and also seen with Eddowes. BS man was peaked cap man and the ripper.
there are many sub mysteries to this case but this aint one of them.IMHO anyway.
The ripper was wearing a peaked cap the night of the double event. that much is sure.

pipeman is irrelevant.

hear hear.

The pipeman may be some secondary agent , this scam had plenty of those hanging around... some of them posing to be "boyfriends".... (or a sad excuse of).

[NotBlamedForNothing]

This may sound incredible, but I think I've worked out who Pipeman is.
I discovered the telltale clue to his identity in the Morning Advertiser, of Oct 3.
It was actually within the text of Edward Spooner's testimony:

By a Juryman. - I did not meet anyone as I was hastening to Berner-street, except Mr. Harris, who was coming out of his house in Tiger Bay when he heard the policeman's whistle. He came running after me.

You see, when Mr Harris heard the police whistle, he started running after Edward Spooner.
Clearly Mr Harris is Pipeman!
I don't know what sort of conditioning would cause this, but certain words or sounds seem to trigger Mr Harris into chasing after whatever friendly local is nearest to him at the time.
Any ideas?

[jerryd]

This may sound incredible, but I think I've worked out who Pipeman is.
I discovered the telltale clue to his identity in the Morning Advertiser, of Oct 3.
It was actually within the text of Edward Spooner's testimony:

By a Juryman. - I did not meet anyone as I was hastening to Berner-street, except Mr. Harris, who was coming out of his house in Tiger Bay when he heard the policeman's whistle. He came running after me.

You see, when Mr Harris heard the police whistle, he started running after Edward Spooner.
Clearly Mr Harris is Pipeman!
I don't know what sort of conditioning would cause this, but certain words or sounds seem to trigger Mr Harris into chasing after whatever friendly local is nearest to him at the time.
Any ideas?

https://forum.casebook.org/forum/rip...-square/page75 (post #1120)

You said Lawende was Pipeman? Now Mr. Harris of Tiger Bay? Which one is it?

[Observer]

Any ideas?

Yes, stop winding up the good people of this Forum

[Wickerman]

This may sound incredible, but I think I've worked out who Pipeman is.
I discovered the telltale clue to his identity in the Morning Advertiser, of Oct 3.
It was actually within the text of Edward Spooner's testimony:

By a Juryman. - I did not meet anyone as I was hastening to Berner-street, except Mr. Harris, who was coming out of his house in Tiger Bay when he heard the policeman's whistle. He came running after me.

You see, when Mr Harris heard the police whistle, he started running after Edward Spooner.
Clearly Mr Harris is Pipeman!
I don't know what sort of conditioning would cause this, but certain words or sounds seem to trigger Mr Harris into chasing after whatever friendly local is nearest to him at the time.
Any ideas?

How does a man coming out of his house in Brunswick st (Tiger Bay) equate to Pipeman on the corner of Berner & Fairclough?
My gut tells me I shouldn't have asked.....

[Al Bundy's Eyes]

This may sound incredible, but I think I've worked out who Pipeman is.
I discovered the telltale clue to his identity in the Morning Advertiser, of Oct 3.
It was actually within the text of Edward Spooner's testimony:

By a Juryman. - I did not meet anyone as I was hastening to Berner-street, except Mr. Harris, who was coming out of his house in Tiger Bay when he heard the policeman's whistle. He came running after me.

You see, when Mr Harris heard the police whistle, he started running after Edward Spooner.
Clearly Mr Harris is Pipeman!
I don't know what sort of conditioning would cause this, but certain words or sounds seem to trigger Mr Harris into chasing after whatever friendly local is nearest to him at the time.
Any ideas?

Which would make Spooner 'Schwartz', leaving the real Israel Schwartz free to be at Mitre Square, where Lawende witnessed him, or some such.....sorry, what was the theory again?

"Any ideas" you ask? I can think of one suggestion.