Did jack kill liz stride?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cogidubnus
    Assistant Commissioner
    • Feb 2012
    • 3266

    #2086
    Hello Lynn

    I feel it only fair to point out though that the vote might go even further the other way if there was a facility to change one's mind in the light of further argument etc...which alas, (if only as a measure of how a good argument might sway hearts and minds), there isn't!

    Shame...it might be (genuinely) interesting...

    All the best

    Dave

    Comment

    • Observer
      Assistant Commissioner
      • Mar 2008
      • 3177

      #2087
      Hi Dave

      I propose a vote

      "Did the Fenians murder Kate Eddowes?"

      Be a bit one sided Begorrah. Wonder what the beginners would make of that!

      Comment

      • Cogidubnus
        Assistant Commissioner
        • Feb 2012
        • 3266

        #2088
        Hi Observer

        We don't seem to agree that often, but your post #2071 regarding Liz Stride really did ring some bells at least

        With regard to Eddowes and the Fenians I wouldn't care to even hazard a guess....I can't even see a point of contact...but it is possible

        All the best

        Dave

        Comment

        • Observer
          Assistant Commissioner
          • Mar 2008
          • 3177

          #2089
          Hi Dave

          Regarding Eddowes and the Fenians, I can't see any evidence whatsoever! It's a non starter.

          Regards

          Observer

          Comment

          • Cogidubnus
            Assistant Commissioner
            • Feb 2012
            • 3266

            #2090
            Regarding Eddowes and the Fenians, I can't see any evidence whatsoever! It's a non starter.
            Well it was your suggestion, was it not?

            Dave

            Comment

            • Jon Guy
              Assistant Commissioner
              • Feb 2008
              • 3154

              #2091
              Originally posted by Cogidubnus View Post
              I feel it only fair to point out though that the vote might go even further the other way if there was a facility to change one's mind in the light of further argument etc...which alas, (if only as a measure of how a good argument might sway hearts and minds), there isn't!

              Shame...it might be (genuinely) interesting...
              Good point, Dave.
              I voted "no" when the thread was started, and it`s a "yes" today.

              Comment

              • lynn cates
                Commisioner
                • Aug 2009
                • 13841

                #2092
                polls

                Hello Dave. Thanks.

                Polls cannot change the past. They are indicators of what a few people think. That's all.

                Cheers.
                LC

                Comment

                • lynn cates
                  Commisioner
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 13841

                  #2093
                  Fianna

                  Hello (again) Dave. Kate? On a Liz thread? And an Irish American group from the 1860's?

                  Good luck with that one!

                  Cheers.
                  LC

                  Comment

                  • curious
                    Chief Inspector
                    • Oct 2009
                    • 1572

                    #2094
                    Originally posted by lynn cates View Post
                    Hello Caroline. Thanks.

                    Could be a result of the musings here. After all, two people died on the same night. Easy.

                    Or it could be that it provides a bump up for the thread and so all the beginners are now drawn in.

                    Cheers.
                    LC
                    Hi, Lynn,
                    And perhaps the increase for is by people who have been considering the aspects for awhile, been on the fence, or back and forth, who have actually taken the time to look at things more closely.

                    Just saying. The more I look, the more I see one killer (and no, I don't know who he is -- don't even have a good guess).

                    Velma

                    Comment

                    • curious
                      Chief Inspector
                      • Oct 2009
                      • 1572

                      #2095
                      Originally posted by Jon Guy View Post
                      Good point, Dave.
                      I voted "no" when the thread was started, and it`s a "yes" today.
                      Hi, Jon,
                      If you don't mind sharing, I'd love to hear the strongest points that changed your mind.

                      thanks,

                      curious

                      Comment

                      • Tom_Wescott
                        Commissioner
                        • Feb 2008
                        • 6996

                        #2096
                        Originally posted by Jon Guy View Post
                        Good point, Dave.
                        I voted "no" when the thread was started, and it`s a "yes" today.
                        Bravo.

                        Yours truly,

                        Tom Wescott

                        Comment

                        • Tom_Wescott
                          Commissioner
                          • Feb 2008
                          • 6996

                          #2097
                          Originally posted by Cogidubnus View Post
                          Hello Lynn

                          I feel it only fair to point out though that the vote might go even further the other way if there was a facility to change one's mind in the light of further argument etc...which alas, (if only as a measure of how a good argument might sway hearts and minds), there isn't!

                          Shame...it might be (genuinely) interesting...

                          All the best

                          Dave
                          I would imagine there'd be many less 'No's' than there are now.

                          Yours truly,

                          Tom Wescott

                          Comment

                          • lynn cates
                            Commisioner
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 13841

                            #2098
                            holding back

                            Hello Velma. Thanks.

                            Hard to imagine the chaps on these boards holding ANYTHING back.

                            Aspects? Perhaps--they died the same night.

                            Cheers.
                            LC

                            Comment

                            • lynn cates
                              Commisioner
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 13841

                              #2099
                              grammatically speaking

                              Hello Tom. Less? You mean "fewer." (heh-heh)

                              Cheers.
                              LC

                              Comment

                              • Wickerman
                                Commissioner
                                • Oct 2008
                                • 14864

                                #2100
                                I haven't a clue how I voted, or when.

                                I do know that after many years conviction of 'No', I am now securely on the fence.
                                Why was there never a 'Maybe' option for fence-sitters?
                                Regards, Jon S.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X