James Kelly vs. Robert Mann?

[Adam Went]

Neither of them should be in the top level of likely suspects, but agree with everyone else that James Kelly is the better of the two. Having said that, and I'll probably get scolded for saying this, but Robert Mann is far from being the worst suspect that's been put forward.....

Cheers,
Adam.

[Tom_Wescott]

Robert Mann isn't and never was a suspect, so he's out from the get-go. As for Kelly, he too doesn't have legs to stand on as a suspect, but at least the argument for him isn't quite so ridiculous.

Yours truly,

Tom Wescott

[Trevor Marriott]

James Kelly ofcourse, he atleast actually killed someone.

Arguing for Mann is about as logical as arguing for Abberline being the ripper, because they both had access to the bodies and scenes. lame

Just to put the record straight Kelly was never proven guilty of any murder

[Madam Red]

Out of those two, I'd say James Kelly.

[FutureM.D.]

James Kelly ofcourse, he atleast actually killed someone.

Arguing for Mann is about as logical as arguing for Abberline being the ripper, because they both had access to the bodies and scenes. lame

[ripper1]

I just want people's opinions here of between these two who do you think was more likely to have been 'Jack the Ripper', and why? I chose these two because they have had the two most recent television shows dedicated to them. Thanks.

I'll post this for RM and the main section for best coverage.