An interesting response. I just wanted to pick up on your last point:-
I think that the reasonable thing to argue is that if he had heard about the murder on Friday noon, then it would not be as reasonable to suggest that he mixed up the days. Which is why I think that he probably did NOT hear about it until some time after - time enough to create a window for doing the mistake I think he did.
In order to accommodate his not hearing about the murder until much later I think we have to resort to pure conjecture - which is fine, but that's all it can be.
We've been through this before though!
Leave a comment: