A major breakthrough

[Henry Flower]

To conclude [....] There are some sources for grandiosity

Ain't that the ****ing truth, Mr "I think I have found him", Mr "Major Breakthrough".

[DJA]

Prolly a zinger John.

[John G]

To conclude. There is no source for a brain disease destroying the capability of thinking. There are some sources for grandiosity.

Regards, Pierre

Are you seriously arguing that brain disease cannot affect cognition?

[Pierre]

I've been away from here due to a broken computer all month. And now I'm back and...some things never change. Like the creator of this thread.

Breakthrough huh? Well actually there was a real breakthrough.

Last month the Canadian government released photos of the rediscovered remains of Sir John Franklin's second ship, HMS Terror, found off King William's Island, and lost with it's sister ship, HMS Erebus, in 1846-48 (?) with the exploration party of 129 men including Sir John himself and all his officers. The "Erebus" was found two years back some 31 miles north of the "Terror's location, also underwater.

It doesn't solve what killed the men of the expedition (lead poisoning in their canned food, scurvy, cold, starvation have been suggested). Nor does it tell us where Sir John's grave is (a piece of writing said he died early in the massive tragedy). But the discovery of the two vessels (now that it is complete) does prove a breakthrough. It turns out that the local Inuit tribes had honestly reported the sinking of both vessels amidst the ice flows, and their approximate locations. Score one for local testimony of the mystery.

And gee...it did not require going to "the archive" on the mystery, nor telling us that the creep who killed several prostitutes, increasingly mutilated them, and left one as a human version of sliced, butchered meat, suffered from (would you believe it) a mental problem. I had thought the individual had nothing worse than an occasional cold!

Jeff

To conclude. There is no source for a brain disease destroying the capability of thinking. There are some sources for grandiosity.

Regards, Pierre

[Geddy2112]

You mean I'm not really a prophet after all?

Joseph came into the lounge to talk to Mary looking rather dejected..

'What is wrong my dear?' she asked..

'It's the carpentry business, it's not doing to well' Joseph replied..

'Don't worry my dear all we have to do is make a little prophet..' said Mary.

[Henry Flower]

Jeff, I couldn't agree more.

[Mayerling]

Yes, this is slightly facetious though. There is a difference between a brain problem and a mental problem. One does not necessarily imply the other.

Nobody disputes that the Whitechapel killer had certain psychological issues. But it is surely open to dispute whether he was or was not mentally ill in a clinical, let alone legal sense. Plenty of similarly savage killers are not, so all this 'oh and there was me thinking he was completely normal!' humour at Pierre's expense is slightly missing the point don't you think?

Well, Henry, your point is well taken. It's just the source of this breakthrough - we have all been through it too often.

Jeff

[Henry Flower]

Yes, this is slightly facetious though. There is a difference between a brain problem and a mental problem. One does not necessarily imply the other.

Nobody disputes that the Whitechapel killer had certain psychological issues. But it is surely open to dispute whether he was or was not mentally ill in a clinical, let alone legal sense. Plenty of similarly savage killers are not, so all this 'oh and there was me thinking he was completely normal!' humour at Pierre's expense is slightly missing the point don't you think?

[Mayerling]

A Reak Breakthrough

I've been away from here due to a broken computer all month. And now I'm back and...some things never change. Like the creator of this thread.

Breakthrough huh? Well actually there was a real breakthrough.

Last month the Canadian government released photos of the rediscovered remains of Sir John Franklin's second ship, HMS Terror, found off King William's Island, and lost with it's sister ship, HMS Erebus, in 1846-48 (?) with the exploration party of 129 men including Sir John himself and all his officers. The "Erebus" was found two years back some 31 miles north of the "Terror's location, also underwater.

It doesn't solve what killed the men of the expedition (lead poisoning in their canned food, scurvy, cold, starvation have been suggested). Nor does it tell us where Sir John's grave is (a piece of writing said he died early in the massive tragedy). But the discovery of the two vessels (now that it is complete) does prove a breakthrough. It turns out that the local Inuit tribes had honestly reported the sinking of both vessels amidst the ice flows, and their approximate locations. Score one for local testimony of the mystery.

And gee...it did not require going to "the archive" on the mystery, nor telling us that the creep who killed several prostitutes, increasingly mutilated them, and left one as a human version of sliced, butchered meat, suffered from (would you believe it) a mental problem. I had thought the individual had nothing worse than an occasional cold!

Jeff

[John G]

You mean I'm not really a prophet after all?

Aw shucks.

Afraid not, David!

[John G]

You don't expect an answer do you?

No, not really!

[Abby Normal]

You mean I'm not really a prophet after all?

Aw shucks.

Sorry David. Predicting that Pierre will be wrong is pretty easy.

[Hercule Poirot]

Pierre,

I know I'm going to regret asking this, but who's your medical expert and was the nature of his opinion?

Doctor Who, of course. But being a senior proctologist he only managed to bust his ass and came out full of ..., well!

[GUT]

Pierre,

I know I'm going to regret asking this, but who's your medical expert and was the nature of his opinion?

You don't expect an answer do you?

[David Orsam]

To be fair, Simon, Pierre is somewhat predictable, although I would therefore agree that you don't need to be a prophet to work him out!

You mean I'm not really a prophet after all?

Aw shucks.