WH Bury Problems

[Rainbow]

There really are some complete morons on this site.

I completely agree with you here John


Rainbow°

[John Wheat]

To be fair, it is regularly said that John Richardson could not have missed Chapman, since he would have smelt her.

Whether that is true or not, I can´t say. I never have corpses lying around in my garden.

But certainly, an indoors corpse would be more likely to smell than an outdoors ditto?

There really are some complete morons on this site.

[Fisherman]

What are you on about?

To be fair, it is regularly said that John Richardson could not have missed Chapman, since he would have smelt her.

Whether that is true or not, I can´t say. I never have corpses lying around in my garden.

But certainly, an indoors corpse would be more likely to smell than an outdoors ditto?

[Fisherman]

Whatever.

Sorry to snatch that juicy bone from your mouth, John. But fair´s fair.

[John Wheat]

If that report was true John, then Bury was innocent even from his wife's death.. get the point ?!

Second, if 100 books said that Bury played card on the trunk his murdered wife was stuffed dead in with her abdomen cut open, and there was NO SMELL .. I am not going to believe them, use your mind John, don't rush like this after pure stupid allegations..


Rainbow°

What are you on about?

[Rainbow]

Those are my sources though.

If that report was true John, then Bury was innocent even from his wife's death.. get the point ?!

Second, if 100 books said that Bury played card on the trunk his murdered wife was stuffed dead in with her abdomen cut open, and there was NO SMELL .. I am not going to believe them, use your mind John, don't rush like this after pure stupid allegations..


Rainbow°

[John Wheat]

Given that the MacKenzie murder was generally NOT regarded as a Ripper murder, although it was much more similar to the real thing than the Bury murder, I think that it must be accepted that the police would decide against Ellen Bury being a Ripper victim.

They would take an initial interest, of course, but I think that is about it.

Whatever.

[Fisherman]

Obviously.

Given that the MacKenzie murder was generally NOT regarded as a Ripper murder, although it was much more similar to the real thing than the Bury murder, I think that it must be accepted that the police would decide against Ellen Bury being a Ripper victim.

They would take an initial interest, of course, but I think that is about it.

[John Wheat]

Hypothetical and a big if but

If burys wife had been murdered indoors but in the heart of Whitechapel and W H Bury could provide a cast iron alibi, would the police at the time suspect her murder to be the work of Jack ?

Obviously.

[John Wheat]

Don't inform me about the case Johny, I asked you how could he almost get away with it..

By saying one of the doctor's report suggested it was a suicide, would that make the case against Bury being the Ripper any better?! you think ?! huh ?!


Rainbow°

Those are my sources though. Do some research.

[StevenOwl]

Hypothetical and a big if but

If burys wife had been murdered indoors but in the heart of Whitechapel and W H Bury could provide a cast iron alibi, would the police at the time suspect her murder to be the work of Jack ?

Some officers probably would have suspected Jack, but no more than those who suspected that any of the other similar murders that fell outside of the timeframe of the C5 as being the work of Jack.

[Rainbow]

You might want to read either Jack the Ripper Unmasked by William Beadle, The Trial of Jack the Ripper by Euan MacPherson or failing that Jack the Ripper There Suspects by The Whitechapel Society Chapter 2 William Bury by Christine Warman or even William (Bill) Beadle's essay Where are we with Bury on this site as you are clearly totally ill informed about Bury. The two books also go into detail about how Bury reportedly played cards on top of the trunk where Ellen's body lay rotting.

Don't inform me about the case Johny, I asked you how could he almost get away with it..

By saying one of the doctor's report suggested it was a suicide, would that make the case against Bury being the Ripper any better?! you think ?! huh ?!


Rainbow°

[Abby Normal]

Hypothetical and a big if but

If burys wife had been murdered indoors but in the heart of Whitechapel and W H Bury could provide a cast iron alibi, would the police at the time suspect her murder to be the work of Jack ?

good question paul g. probably.

[paul g]

Hypothetical and a big if but

If burys wife had been murdered indoors but in the heart of Whitechapel and W H Bury could provide a cast iron alibi, would the police at the time suspect her murder to be the work of Jack ?

[John Wheat]

Explain this if YOU are aware of it !



Rainbow°

You might want to read either Jack the Ripper Unmasked by William Beadle, The Trial of Jack the Ripper by Euan MacPherson or failing that Jack the Ripper There Suspects by The Whitechapel Society Chapter 2 William Bury by Christine Warman or even William (Bill) Beadle's essay Where are we with Bury on this site as you are clearly totally ill informed about Bury. The two books also go into detail about how Bury reportedly played cards on top of the trunk where Ellen's body lay rotting.