Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Did Jack "Pose" his victims.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • smezenen
    replied
    kensei,
    looking at the photo of Mary kelly, does it look like the hand is inside the abdominal cavity? Or is it just over the cavity?

    My opinion is over, thus it may have just fallen into this position. I used to believe it was inside until I saw the colorized photo. http://forum.casebook.org/showpost.p...3&postcount=59

    Leave a comment:


  • kensei
    replied
    I agree with your definitions, and I think the only example of posing JTR did would have been to stick Mary Kelly's left hand into her abdominal cavity, though I can't guess what specific meaning it had for him. Other than that, I wouldn't say any of the other bodies appear to have been posed in any way.

    Leave a comment:


  • smezenen
    started a topic Did Jack "Pose" his victims.

    Did Jack "Pose" his victims.

    I have had many wonderful debates on the topic of whether Jack posed the bodies of his victims. these discussions have always been on threads dedicated to other topics so I am starting this thread to continue the discussion. All comments are welcome.

    To start the discussion I think we must begin with a distinction between posing and positioning. Below is how I see the distinction.

    Posing is to put the body into a position that would increase the horror effect or send a message. In other words to put the body in a purposely unnatural position. An example of posing would be to nail the corpse to a wall in the form of a cross or place it in a seated position at a dinner table.

    Positioning is how the killer moves the body or body parts in order to accomplish his goal. In other word putting the body or parts of the body in a naturally incidental position. An example may be, the intestines placed beside the body or tossed over a shoulder in order to get them out of the way.

    So the questions go out:
    1-Are the above definitions of positioning -Vs- posing correct in your view?

    2-Do you thing Jack posed bodies or is the way the bodies are found just a result of natural positioning?

    I don’t know how / don’t have the ability to make this thread a poll. Maybe there is someone more knowledgeable / capable than I that could / would start a poll.
Working...
X