The GSG - Did Jack write it? POLL

[Batman]

I cited Paul Begg on Pipeman but this isn't sufficient for you...

...but that's okay because the contemporary view beats a conspiracy theory with even less, if any, evidence for it all.

Btw, your clinical trial as you call it just guesses peoples heights involved.

[lynn cates]

implication

Hello (yet again) Batman. Thanks.

"Warren uses the GSG to demonstrate JtR wasn't a socialist or a Jew."

He used it in his private speculation. He thought someone was trying to implicate the Jews.

By the way, he changed his mind about Socialists, but AFTER the Jonas story.

Cheers.
LC

[c.d.]

Warren uses the GSG to demonstrate JtR wasn't a socialist or a Jew.

http://forum.casebook.org/showpost.php?p=334002&postcount=1

No, Warren is giving his opinion as to whether JTR was a socialist or a Jew. And there is always the possibility that the author of the GSG was simply trying to throw the police off track (a theory supported by Smith).

You also overlooked Smith's comment -- "It may have been written by the murderer, or it may not."

c.d.

[Batman]

Hello (yet again) Batman. Thanks.

"Warren uses the GSG to demonstrate JtR wasn't a socialist or a Jew."

He used it in his private speculation. He thought someone was trying to implicate the Jews.

By the way, he changed his mind about Socialists, but AFTER the Jonas story.

Cheers.
LC

So? How does this show it wasn't a contemporary view? It was his view. I agree with him. Nothing novel on this from me.

[lynn cates]

pulse

Hello Batman. Thanks.

If you are checking for a pulse, do you check the hand you are next (right) or the one lodged partly under her body (left)?

Cheers.
LC

[c.d.]

"We Jews are tired of being blamed for nothing. So take that."

Anti-Semitic?

Hello Lynn,

Yes. I don't understand why more people don't see that as a reasonable interpretation. Not to say that that is the correct interpretation but it certainly seems reasonable.

Would you agree that where you see graffiti disparaging a particular group that you are almost always going to see graffiti from someone in that group firing back? All it would take for a Jew to respond would be a wall and a piece of chalk.

c.d.

[lynn cates]

authority

Hello Batman. Thanks.

"I cited Paul Begg on Pipeman but this isn't sufficient for you..."

If you wish to advert to authority--rather than thinking for yourself--why not quote Paul on Kosminski? You know, the JEWISH suspect? (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[Batman]

No, Warren is giving his opinion as to whether JTR was a socialist or a Jew. And there is always the possibility that the author of the GSG was simply trying to throw the police off track (a theory supported by Smith).

You also overlooked Smith's comment -- "It may have been written by the murderer, or it may not."

c.d.

What do you mean no? He invokes the gsg as evidence JtR wasn't a Jew. You said I was only one to do this. Clearly the contemporary says otherwise. Its nothing new at all.

[c.d.]

Please name one person who corroborated Schwartz as being on Berner.

That is only evidence that no one else saw him not that he was lying. Don't we have other witnesses who are uncorroborated? Are we to doubt their stories simply because no one else was there at the time?

c.d.

[Batman]

Hello Batman. Thanks.

"I cited Paul Begg on Pipeman but this isn't sufficient for you..."

If you wish to advert to authority--rather than thinking for yourself--why not quote Paul on Kosminski? You know, the JEWISH suspect? (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

I addressed this exact point 2 pages back. So you don't reference sources? I think you are getting confused again. You just referenced someone a few posts ago. Wow.

[c.d.]

What do you mean no? He invokes the gsg as evidence JtR wasn't a Jew. You said I was only one to do this. Clearly the contemporary says otherwise. Its nothing new at all.

Again, he is simply giving his opinion that doesn't necessarily make it so.

c.d.

[lynn cates]

old fella

Hello John. Thanks for the kind words.

Might die of old age first. (heh-heh)

Cheers.
LC

[Batman]

Again, he is simply giving his opinion that doesn't necessarily make it so.

c.d.

The fact he gave one that is the same as mine means my view isn't unsupported in the contemporary. That's all.

Swanson dismissed the idea someone else besides BSman killed her based on the investigation. So did they investigate or not?

[lynn cates]

yes

Hello CD. Thanks.

Absolutely.

Cheers.
LC

[Harry D]

The argument is that the police immediately knew the nature of the graffito was anti-semitic, which is what prompted Arnold and Warren to have it erased before it would invoke an anti-semitic riot. I must be missing something because this doesn't add up. Surely a statement of Jewish solidarity from the killer would turn the locals against the Jewish immigrants, rather than an anti-semitic slur which implies the killer was a gentile?